Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Sila Pilih A, B atau C.




Jewish Doctor Refuses to treat Nazi Tatoo Patient



A 46 year old Jewish doctor from Paderborn, Germany abandoned a patient and refused to perform surgery on him after he saw a tattoo with the Nazi Party Symbol in the patient’s arm. The Jewish Chronicle, which exposed the affair, claims that when the 38 year old patient arrived for surgery, the doctor saw thet symbol on his arm, the same symbol that the Nazi Party adopted during World War II.
It was also reported that the doctor told the patient’s wife that he was Jewish and that his conscience forbade him from performing surgery on the patient. When a different doctor arrived, the surgery was performed and the patient was transferred to the recovery room.
It should be noted that throughout the affair, the patient’s life was not in imminent danger. The incident nevertheless spawned a heated debate amongst the German medical community. Some doctors who expressed their opinion held that the doctor violated the Hippocratic Oath through his actions, an oath that requires every doctor to give medical treatment to everyone regardless of religion, race, or sex.
On the other hand, some voices were heard in support of the doctor’s actions, and claimed that since the doctor had a moral, conscientious objection to the tattoo, that prevented him from granting the appropriate medical treatment to the patient. More than that, they also emphasized that it was the doctor’s right not to treat him and that he did the right thing by leaving the room.
One way or the other, the tattooed patient will be put on trial as according to German law, it is forbidden to tattoo Nazi symbols on one’s body. The punishment for such a crime is three years.
::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::;
- Subject of an intense debate.

Hippocratic Oath VS Morality & To Do No Harm.


Kalau anda ditempat pakar bedah itu, apa yang anda akan lakukan?


a) Terus lakukan pembedahan itu dengan se professional mungkin, sambil menolak pelbagai andaian dan idea idea jahat yang bermain di dalam minda.


b) Menolak untuk lakukan pembedahan ini, dengan alasan yang sama seperti pakar bedah Jerman ini berikan, dikhuatiri akan memberi kesan buruk terhadap pesakit(kerana minda asyik terganggu semasa membedah).


c) Terus melakukan pembedahan ini, dengan niat utk datangkan kesengsaraan/membalas dendam  kepada pesakit Nazi itu, secara terselindung,yakni contohnya dengan sengaja men-sub standardkan mutu pembedahan anda.
Sila pilih, A, B, atau C ?

22 comments:

  1. kalaulah doktor yek...

    emmm..pilih A...konon baik..hehe

    ReplyDelete
  2. saya kunci lirik ini!!!!!!

    eh, salah tempat ek? kekekek

    ReplyDelete
  3. rasanya saya ambik 1, eh A !!!

    sebagai professional dan kerjayanya menyelamatkan org.. kan..

    ReplyDelete
  4. saya pilih D

    pura2 pengsan pastu suruh dr lain buat~

    ble macamtu daddy?

    ReplyDelete
  5. KOG - doc sendiri pun boleh pening kepala nak menjawab tauuu

    ReplyDelete
  6. ati- hmmmm..doc contoh la ni ye..:)

    ReplyDelete
  7. GB -- anda tidak menjawab soalan dgn tepat. Tettttttttt

    ReplyDelete
  8. bujal X - baik ko pilih jawapan X...heheheh

    ReplyDelete
  9. saye pilih untuk lakukan C..hahahaha..ternyata kejam..

    xde lah..jwpn doc plak ape?

    sekian, dikomen oleh:

    - zie-yg-mls-nk-log in-

    ReplyDelete
  10. saya pilih E...boleh? hahaha!!!

    ReplyDelete
  11. 'do no harm'
    kadang2 sungguh terseksa jiwa raga dgn ayat itu =P

    ReplyDelete
  12. hani - awat? ko selalu DO harm ke....:)

    ReplyDelete
  13. erm

    A mungkin. positip positip.hahahahaha

    ReplyDelete
  14. weii.. takde la
    aku SAYANGGGGG patients aku! hahaha
    sesekali jer terasa nak buat jahat kat patients yg aku tak sayang :P

    ReplyDelete
  15. kalau aku jawab...
    kang ada orang report aku kat MMA kang!!!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hani lagi - aku pun begituuuuuuu...:)

    ReplyDelete
  17. DrSinga - siapa kaki report tuh..meh sini gue cili cilikan mulutnya...

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...